Spectra Breast Pump Comparison: S1 vs S2

Spectra Breast Pump Comparison: S1 vs S2

This post contains affiliate links. If you click on a link and choose to make a purchase, I will receive a commission at no additional cost to you. See our affiliate disclosure page for more information.

If you are looking to buy a breast pump, then Spectra is one of the best brands that is on the market today. There are two models which are generally considered the best and these are the S1 and S2. If you are wondering which of these options is best for you, then the following article has all the information you need.

What Factors Need To Be Considered When Choosing A Breast Pump?

One of the main difficulties with buying a breast pump is that you are not able to try it out before you buy. This is quite a big deal when you consider that you may be using the pump every day.

When you are choosing a pump, it is important to think about what you will need to get out of it. Some factors to think about could include:

1. Mobility.

You need to think about whether the pump needs to be plugged into a socket or if it is more portable.

2. Noise.

Most people would probably prefer a breast pump that does not make too much noise.

3. Features.

The features of breast pumps can vary considerably between the different models so you need to think carefully about any specific features that you want.

4. Price.

While you should not choose a breast pump just because it is the cheapest option, you do not want to pay more than you need to.

How Are The S1 And S2 Models Similar?

Spectra – S1 Plus Electric Breast Milk Pump

Spectra – S2 Plus Electric Breast Milk Pump

There are a lot of similarities between the two models. Both of them have the following features.

  • They are double pump so have the choice to pump from one breast or both at the same time.
  • An auto-timer so you always know when you should stop pumping.
  • A backlight so you can see the menus and timer in the dark.
  • Settings that allow you to adjust suction and cycle control.
  • The ability to check the total amount of hours you have been pumping.
  • A two-year warranty that is effective from the date of purchase, not the date of manufacture.

How Do The S1 and S2 Models Differ?

Power SourceBuilt-in Battery
Plug-in to wall
Pump TimerYesYes
Speed ControlYesYes
Weight3 lbs3 lbs
Night LightYesYes
LCD ScreenYesYes

The biggest difference between the two models is that the S1 has a rechargeable battery, while this is not the case for the S2.

The S2 model is also slightly smaller. In theory this does make the S2 more portable, but in reality, you would need to be connected to a power supply.

Frequently Asked Questions About Spectra Breast Pumps

What Are The Advantages Of Spectra Breast Pumps?

Reviews of Spectra Breast Pumps tend to focus on the following advantages.

They are comfortable – People who have used different brands find that the Spectra pumps are more gentle. They can often pump for longer periods of time without their breasts becoming sore.

They are quiet – The pumps make hardly any noise when they are in use. People have reported being able to chat on the phone while pumping, without the person on the other end ever realizing what they are doing.

High levels of customer service – Many people have found Spectra to be very helpful if they have had issues with their pump. Their customer service agents can be contacted in a number of ways, including on Facebook Messenger, and they will always do what they can to help.

Are There Any Disadvantages?

There are breast pumps on the market from other brands that are smaller and therefore easier to move around. However, this only becomes a real disadvantage if you plan to be very mobile while you are expressing your milk. You will probably find it a lot more comfortable to sit down, and for this both Spectra models work really well.

It can also be quite difficult to get hold of any replacement parts for a Spectra breast pump. Depending on where you live, there may not be a store nearby that has these parts available. One solution is to make sure you stock up of any parts you think you may need in the future. This means that you won’t be left not being able to use your pump if something does go wrong.

Is A Breast Pump Essential?

It depends on your personal circumstances, but many women consider breast pumps to be essential pieces of equipment. Being able to express milk means that your partner is able to help out with the night feeds. It can also be useful if you decide to go back to work after the baby has been born. You can express the milk that they will need for the time you are at work and it can be then be kept until it is needed by your baby.

Can I Get A Spectra Breast Pump Through My Insurance?

You may be able to get a basic breast pump through your insurance. This may not cover a Spectra pump, but you may be able to pay the difference if your insurance company agrees. If the cost of the pump is covered by the insurance, then this is more likely to be the S2 model as this is is the cheaper option.


It is definitely worth spending the time to research a breast pump before you buy it, as this will make it more likely that it will be suitable for your purpose. If you have any friends or family that have recently had a baby, then you can ask them for their advice. If you do not know anyone in this situation, then online reviews can also be very helpful.

Either Spectra model is a good choice, but you may find that one model has the particular features that you are looking for. Once you understand what each pump can offer you, then you will be in a better position to make a decision.

For many people, the rechargeable battery that comes with the S1 model makes it the best choice. However, if this feature is something that you can live without, then the S2 is cheaper and may even be covered by your insurance. The decision you make will come down to your own personal circumstances and preferences, but you will not go far wrong with a Spectra breast pump.

Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.